Button 3 Button 1 Button 2 Button 4 Button 5 Button 6
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Google
630-932-9100
Free Initial Consultation | Se habla español 630-932-9100
Mevorah Law Offices LLC
630-932-9100
DuPage County Attorneys

LOMBARD

900 E. Roosevelt Road, Lombard, IL 60148

Phone: 630-932-9100

BLOOMINGDALE

134 N. Bloomingdale Road, Bloomingdale, IL 60108

Phone: 630-529-4761

ST. CHARLES

333 N. Randall Road, Suite 104, St. Charles, IL 60175

Phone: 630-443-0600

JOLIET

58 N. Chicago Street, Suite 500, Joliet, IL 60432

Phone: 815-727-4500

CHICAGO

105 W. Madison Street, Suite 2200, Chicago, IL 60602

Phone: 630-932-9100

What is a “Particular Social Group?”

Posted on in Immigration
  • Font size: Larger Smaller
  • Hits: 1708
  • Print

seeking asylum, particular social group, Chicago immigration attorneyIn the United States, those applying for asylum must qualify under the 1951 Geneva Convention definition of a refugee. This means that they must be able to prove a “well-founded fear” of returning to their home country because of their race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group (PSG). While four of these grounds are fairly straightforward, the ‘membership in a particular social group’ criteria is often used as a catch-all of sorts. Its definition remains disputed in U.S. law.

General Definition

Generally speaking, many judges define a particular social group as a group of people viewed as a threat by a government based on one characteristic they all share, usually an immutable (unchangeable) physical or mental trait or an experience. Examples in the past have included homosexuals, former gang members or people of a shared ethnicity. One trend that seems to help define the term further is that the characteristic shared must not be subjective. For example, “rich people” would be a poor attempt to define a particular social group, because “rich” is entirely subjective.

Another factor that many judges seem to consider is if the group is visible as a PSG within its own society. Victims of rape at the hands of soldiers may be a particular social group in the sense that they share a characteristic which is not transient or subjective, but they are often invisible in their home society. If a group is invisible in its home society, there is no real reason for them to fear persecution. In short, a particular social group is most likely to be recognized if it is comprised of people who share some kind of immutable characteristic (experience, ethnicity, sexual orientation, etc.), and if it is at least somewhat visible in the home country.

Application in the System

The U.S. immigration system has only just begun to give credence to many particular social groups that one might assume were already classified as such. However, many cases do not reach the courts or are not appealed to a court where a final ruling can be made. There remains a fair amount of debate as to what actually constitutes a PSG, and rulings have been inconsistent, but the definition is widening, which can be a salvation for some that would otherwise have found it difficult to gain asylum.

The most recent example is in September 2014, when a court ruled in Matter of A-R-C-G- that female survivors of domestic violence in Guatemala who were “unable to leave their relationships” constituted a PSG for asylum purposes. While the Board of Immigration Appeals made it clear that particular social group status would still be determined on a case by case basis, A-R-C-G- makes it easier for those in gender-based PSGs to qualify, provided there is enough governmental involvement (or lack of control over those involved) in their persecution.

Contact an Experienced Asylum Attorney

It is always a good idea to apply for asylum under as many grounds as you think are possible, but “particular social group” has always been a bit of a wild card. Even with trends now changing to be a little more clearly defined for the potential asylee, having competent representation is critical. The Chicago immigration attorneys at Mevorah Law Offices LLC are ready, willing, and able to put the benefit of their years of experience to work for you. Contact us today to discuss your options.

  • DuPage County Immigration Lawyers
  • Elite Lawyers
  • National Association of Distinguished Counsel
  • Top 40 Under 40
  • 2015 Top 40 Lawyers Under 40
  • Super Lawyers

Let us start helping you with a FREE initial consultation.

NOTE: Fields with a * indicate a required field.
*
*
*

One Stop For All Your Legal Needs

Whether you are going through a divorce, injured in an accident, need to file a workers' compensation claim, charged with a crime, immigrating to the United States, or need to file for bankruptcy, Mevorah Law Offices LLC can help. Our trial lawyers have over 35 years of experience helping clients throughout Northern Illinois from five offices in Lombard, Bloomindale, Joliet, St. Charles, and Chicago.

Steven Mevorah has assembled experienced attorneys under one roof so that his clients need not search for a new attorney each time they need help. Mr. Mevorah has also established a wide network of additional attorneys so that his clients merely need to stop by Mevorah Law Offices LLC to find the attorney they need.

Client Focused Representation

Our practice is focused on meeting your needs with flexible hours and locations to serve you:

  • Free initial consultations
  • Saturday and evening appointments available
  • Home and hospital visits if your injuries prevent you from traveling
  • Multiple locations throughout Chicagoland
  • Veteran trial attorneys
  • Experienced negotiators
  • Payment plans available
  • Cash, check, or credit card accepted